Suboxone - A New Treatment Paradigm Part Two

In Part One of this article I described the problems with traditional treatment of opiate addiction. Suboxone is a revolutionary alternative.

Suboxone consists of two drugs; buprenorphine and naloxone. The naloxone is irrelevant if the addict uses the medication properly, but if the tablet is dissolved in water and injected the naloxone will cause instant withdrawal. When suboxone is used correctly, the naloxone is destroyed in the liver shortly after uptake from the intestines and has no therapeutic effect. Buprenorphine is the active substance; it is absorbed under the tongue (and throughout the mouth) but destroyed by the liver if swallowed. There is a formulation of buprenorphine without naloxone called subutex; I have used this formulation when the patient has apparent problems from naloxone, including headaches after dosing with suboxone. I have also treated addicts who have had gastric bypass, where the first part of the intestine is bypassed and the stomach contents empty into a more distal part of the small intestine. In such cases the naloxone escapes first pass metabolism, the process with normal anatomy where the drug is taken up by the duodenum and transferred directly to the liver by the portal vein, where it is quickly and completely destroyed. After gastric bypass naloxone can be taken up by portions of the intestine that are not served by the portal system, causing blood levels of naloxone sufficient to cause brief, relatively mild withdrawal symptoms.

Buprenorphine has a ceiling effectthe narcotic effect of the drug increases with increasing dose up to about one or two mg, but then the effect plateaus and higher amounts of buprenorphine do not increase narcosis. The average patient usually takes 12-24 mg of suboxone per day, and quickly becomes tolerant to the effects of buprenorphine (buprenorphine does have significant narcotic potency, but the potency usually pales in comparison to the degree of tolerance found in active opiate addicts).. The opiate receptors in the brain of the addict become completely bound up with buprenorphine, and the effects of any other opiate medication are blocked. Once the addict is tolerant to the correct dose of suboxone, the buprenorphine that is bound to their opiate receptors reduces cravings and prevents the effectsand so the use–of other opiates. Suboxone is very effective in preventing relapse; the choose to use issue is effectively removed by the fact that use would require the addict to go through several days of withdrawal in order to remove the receptor blockade and allow other opiates to have an effect. Given addicts attitudes toward withdrawal, the appeal of this choice is quite low. The only real problem with suboxone treatment relates to specificity. With suboxone, the addict stays off opiates, but there is nothing to prevent the substitution of alcohol. On the other hand, naltrexone reduces alcohol cravings by blocking opiate receptors, and it is quite likely that suboxone, through its similar mechanism, will reduce alcohol cravings as well. Such an effect has been reported to me by a number of suboxone patients, but has not been reported in the literature at this point. The suboxone patients who move from one substance to another will likely require an approach that demands total sobriety. But for pure opiate lovers, other benefits of suboxone are that only mild (and possibly medicated) withdrawal is required to start treatment, the drug is usually covered by insurers, prescribing restrictions are minor, and there are fewer stigmas associated with maintenance than there are with methadone.

As I stated in part one of this article, I predict that suboxone will eventually be the standard treatment for opiate addiction, and will change the treatment approach for other substance addictions as well. My only reservation with this statement is that it is unclear how the current recovering community will respond to patients treated with suboxone. If suboxone patients are rejected by the recovering community, what will be the long-term outcome of their addictions when the substance is removed but the personalities and issues remain untreated? Is it a given that all addicts have a disease that requires group therapy? As things stand now, addicts maintained on suboxone are often referred for addiction counseling. But the exact message to deliver with counseling is debatable. In many ways, a patient maintained with suboxone becomes similar to a patient with hypertension treated for life with medicationthe underlying problem persists, but the active disease is held in remission. If the uncontrolled use of opiates is effectively treated, is that enough? Should counseling be focused on removing the shame of having the disease of addiction, and on encouraging the treated addicts to get on with their normal lives? Or should we continue to see addiction as a consequence of a deeper problem or faulty character structure, which requires groups and meetings if one hopes to become normal? Unfortunately the use of suboxone runs counter to successful adoption of sobriety through 12-step programs, which in the first step require acceptance of the fact that the addict is powerless over the substancethat there is no amount of will power that will allow the addict to control the deadly effects of the drug. By using suboxone the addict may develop the impression that he/she has control, particularly if suboxone becomes popular on the street for self-medication of withdrawal.

Before suboxone, the only option for opiate addicts was to lose a sufficient number of thingsfamily, employment, freedom, healthto cause them to accept treatment and recovery. Only a small fraction of addicts recovered, and only after significant lossesand relapse rates were high. Suboxone is an amazing breakthrough; one that for the first time allows treatment of addicts early in the course of their illness, and that reliably induces remission in most patients. But there are some things to be concerned about, that have the potential to reduce the effectiveness of this amazing new drug and treatment approach. First, some insurers demand that the drug be used only short-term, in some cases for only three weeks! This requirement totally misses the nature of addiction, and ignores the known high relapse rate after short-term use of suboxone (and why wouldnt it be high?). Some physicians use the medication in this short-term way; hopefully the motivations for this ineffective treatment method are not related to the limits placed on the numbers of maintenance patients per physician. Other physicians will transfer their attitudes toward opiate agonists to the use of suboxone, and place constant downward pressure on the daily dose of suboxone. This approach is not appropriate with suboxone; the value of the drug requires adequate dosing to achieve the long half-life and repression of cravings. At doses of less than 8 mg, suboxone becomes more similar to a pure agonist; one might as well be giving small doses of hydrocodone to prevent withdrawal. There is no reason beyond drug cost to reduce the dose, as tolerance is limited by the ceiling effect that occurs with relatively low doses. In other words, higher doses of suboxone do not result in eventual higher degrees of withdrawal. Another issue is that the medication is sometimes prescribed carelessly, without emphasizing the need to dose once per day. Patients left to their own devices will start using the medication multiple times per day as a prn medication, and will remain in the same addiction behavior that brought them to treatment. Once per day dosing is important because it allows the addictive behavior to be extinguished over time. Initially patients will have increased anxiety as they lose the distraction and placebo effect of frequent drug use. But over time the anxiety will fade, and the huge void left by the removal of addictive obsession will allow the development of relationships and other positive character traits that were forced out by their addiction.

Given the time pressures and payment structures of modern medicine, suboxone may eventually replace residential treatment as a more reliable, less costly alternative. I believe that the time has come to replace the recovery model with a new remission model, which allows treatment of a much higher percentage of users at an earlier stage of disease. With time, will we find analogous agents that provide a low level of intoxication in return for receptor blockade? While not likely with alcohol, such an outcome is certainly within the bounds of imagination for cocaine, benzodiazepines, and barbiturates. While it is true that daily use of a partial agonist would represent a reversal from our current approach where all intoxicating substances are to be avoided, it is also true that the current approach has no bragging rights based on outcome. Finally, perhaps the adoption of a remission model will lessen the time until opiate and other addictions carry as much moral stigma as hypertension or diabetestwo other diseases that are generally treatable, but that require long-term use of medications.

Jeffrey Junig MD PhD lives in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, and is a psychiatrist and pain physician in solo, independent practice. Additional information can be found at the web site of his chronic pain and addiction practice, Wisconsin Opiate Management Center, or at Fond du Lac Psychiatry. He is available for patient care, consultations, or educational presentations.

Houston Suboxone Codeine Rehab
Suboxone is a treatment for dependence on opiod drugs. Morphine and codeine are derived from opium. Many prescription painkillers contain opiods inclu...

The Drug That Kills - Heroin
100% Pure HeroinPure heroin, which is a white powder with a nasty taste, is rarely sold on the streets anywhere. Most illicit heroin is a powder varyi...

How to Choose Alcohol and Drug Addiction Treatment
In today's world, the effects of alcohol and drug addiction on the individual are great and the cumulative effects on our society are staggering. It h...

Alcoholism Treatment Program - Discover What to Expect From Inpatient Treatment
If elected to enter into an inpatient alcoholism treatment program, you certainly have numerous questions. More than anything else, you likely are wo...

Alcohol Addiction Treatment in VIrginia, Maryland and Washington, DC
You can search the states of Virginia, Maryland and Washington and find hundreds of alcohol rehabs providing alcohol addiction treatment. Some of the ...

Alcoholism Treatment Methods - Do They Work?
Thanks to intensive research and development for decades, there are a multitude of alcoholism treatment methods available. Alcohol abuse or alcoholis...

Drug Addiction Treatment - An Overview
Research suggests that there are 5 untreated people to every treated person when it comes to drug addiction treatment. If you are one among those who ...

Prometa Clinics - Drug Treatment Centers
PROMETA Clinics chemical dependence treatment differs from traditional drug and alcohol addiction treatment centers by focusing on the biology of drug...

Venturing Into The Unknown
Yet another year has sped past. Before we knew it, weve been pitch forked into the New Year! Can we make our life in 2005 substantively different or w...

Change Begins from Within Through Paradigm Shifts to Your Belief System
Many individuals and that includes organizations which are just groups of individuals united to achieve specific goals continually seek new answers to...

Depression Treatment
When it comes to mental illness, people are often reluctant to consult a physician or health professional, yet the treatment of depression as soon as ...

Addiction Treatment
You are in great trouble if you are addicted or live with an addict. Due to addiction, most of the addicts die and also take down their family members...

What You Should Know About Dealing With Addiction, Part 2
Help Options For Dealing With AddictionFamily and friends who help their loved ones deal with addiction may suggest, encourage, or insist upon a varie...

Objective Of Drug Rehab, Alcohol Rehab and Dual Diagnosis Programs
The main objective of drug rehab programs is to free you from the bondage of drug abuse and alcoholism. These programs help you to discover newer ways...

Help For The Alcoholic
Question: If an alcoholic is unwilling to get help, what can you do about it?Alcoholics don't respond very well to advice, suggestions, or threats. On...

Wagon Train

Alcohol rehab: Joaquin's in; Billy Joel's out. Phoenix checked himself in to dry out two weeks ago, while the Piano Man has completed a 30-day stint at Betty Ford

By Gary Susman

Joaquin Phoenix has been vexed, terribly vexed, by alcoholism. According to his publicist, the 30-year-old star of The Village checked himself into an undisclosed clinic two weeks ago in order to quit drinking. ''He was uncomfortable with the way that he was living his life and found the courage to deal with the disease,'' rep Susan Patricola said in a statement.

Phoenix has some strong second-hand familiarity with the perils of addiction. He was with big brother River on the night in 1993 that the Stand By Me star died of a drug overdose. And he recently finished filming the role of Johnny Cash in the biopic Walk the Line, which reportedly focuses on how June Carter (Reese Witherspoon) helped the Man in Black overcome his abuse of alcohol and speed.

Meanwhile, Billy Joel has finished a 30-day treatment for alcohol abuse at the Betty Ford Center, his publicist tells the Associated Press. Rep Claire Mercuri said that the 55-year-old rocker checked out of the California clinic on Sunday and returned to the Long Island, N.Y. home he shares with 23-year-old Kate Lee, who became the Piano Man's third wife last year. It's the longest time he's spent in rehab; in 2002, he spent two weeks trying to kick booze at Connecticut's Silver Hill Hospital. ''He looks really fit,'' a friend who saw Joel on Sunday told the New York Daily News. ''He's dedicated to a healthy and sober lifestyle.''